I’m not sure that anyone does a cheesy reality show quite like the British. Sure, the US may have mastered such competitive fare as Survivor or The Amazing Race, but when we want some tongue-in-cheek fun, we know which nation to turn to for inspiration. After all, the nation that gave us Pop Idol and Strictly Come Dancing (which, of course, spawned American Idol and Dancing With the Stars) knows a thing or two about light-hearted, disposable fun.
I’d Do Anything, which tracks the search for the next West End star — in this case, to play Nancy or the titular role in the musical Oliver! — fits the bill perfectly. It has all the hallmarks of a quality reality show: a diverse cast, heart-breaking human interest stories, and a prize that’s actually worth something. Granted, I’m a sucker for a good musical, so I’m a bit biased, but here are a few more reasons to watch the show:
1. It’s a chance to learn that English people can be just as rubbish as Americans when it comes to mimicking a Cockney accent. Dick Van Dyke can sleep a bit easier.
2. The show is remarkably self-aware, at least in terms of its own camp value. The fact that each appearance of Andrew Lloyd Webber is greeted with the opening strains of Phantom of the Opera suggests the editors are amused or tipsy, if not both. Plus, it’s hosted by the camp-tastic Graham Norton. American Idol should be so lucky.
3. Unlike most American reality shows, the writers assume that the audience already knows a thing or two, happily including the phrase “scarier than Bill Sykes with a hangover” without a note of explanation.
4. Two words: John Barrowman. He may be dark and grim on Torchwood these days, but he spends his time on I’ll Do Anything randomly breaking into song with a gigantic grin on his face or showing off his bum in an effort to demonstrate how dirty Nancy should be. The man is irresistible.
5. Repeated use of the phrase, “You’re going to nancy school!” It just never gets old.
I’d Do Anything airs on BBC1, 7pm, Saturday, or all week on the BBC iPlayer for those who refuse to stay home on a Saturday night to watch a reality show (or at least refuse to admit it).